New Jersey Supreme Court Tells Insurer to Cover Autism Therapy

The New Jersey Supreme Court has done what Canada's Supreme Court would not do, it has ordered a health insurance plan for state workers to cover the cost of therapy for a 5 year old autistic boy. As reported in the Star-Ledger online the therapy cost the boy's family about $35,000 per year. The NJSC upheld two earlier appellate rulings:

The Supreme Court upheld two appellate rulings that came down in January and May 2007. The January decision said the commission could not deny treatment for "a class of dependents, notably afflicted children, based on the nature of their mental illness."

In Canada we can sometimes be smug about our "universal" health care coverage believing our system of health care coverage to be superior to that of our American friends. But in Auton the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that governments which provide our primary health care coverage in Canada were not required to provide coverage for ABA treatment for autistic children. For autistic children in Canada, and their families, Auton meant in effect that little, if any, reliance could be placed on Section 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
15.(1) Every individual is equal before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law without discrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability.

The New Jersey Supreme Court ordered the state health benefits commission to pay the Micheletti family's bills in two weeks with 30 days to pay future bills. In Canada, by contrast, the families involved came away from the precedent setting Auton decision with something much less substantial - the sympathy of the Court - as expressed by Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin:

One sympathizes with the petitioners, and with the decisions below ordering the public health system to pay for their therapy. However, the issue before us is not what the public health system should provide, which is a matter for Parliament and the legislature. The issue is rather whether the British Columbia Government’s failure to fund these services under the health plan amounted to an unequal and discriminatory denial of benefits under that plan, contrary to s. 15 of the Charter. Despite their forceful argument, the petitioners fail to establish that the denial of benefits violated the Charter.

Autism Health Insurance - Texas Governor Perry Signs Autism Insurance BIll

"Great things can be achieved, with early intervention, like with this one, He's making miraculous progress,"

- Suvi Aika, Mother of 5 year old diagnosed with autism at age 2

It is very enouraging to see the progress toward health insurance coverage for autism being made in the United States. Maybe if enough US states provide coverage Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper will be persuaded to do more than provide a lack lustre one page web site to help the cause of autistic children in Canada.

Autism insurance bill gets Governor's approval

06:29 PM CDT on Friday, June 22, 2007

By ELISE HU
KVUE News

Texas will soon require health insurance companies to provide coverage for children with Autism, under a bill signed by the governor last week.

http://www.kvue.com/news/local/stories/062207kvuechildautism-jj.34b9fb0.html